http://www.dsti.net/Information/News/67877
加拿大CH-148“龍捲風”海軍直升機:遲到總比不到強?
2011-05-27
[據美國《防務工業日報》2011年5月中旬報導]加拿大的海軍直升機換代項目由於其漫長的專案進程而成為軍用採辦專案的教科書,但很不幸是反面教材。由於加拿大海軍的“海王”直升機逐漸老化,加拿大準備為海軍採購一型新的直升機,但由於政治分歧和考慮不周,使一個本應很簡單的現貨採購項目進行了25年,且一直被專案終止、訴訟、重新招標等各種問題困擾。最後,加拿大軍方重於決定採用西科斯基公司在H-92“超級鷹”基礎上升級的CH-148“龍捲風”,該機將部署在海軍的艦艇及基地。
S-92“超級鷹”作為一型民機取得了很大的成功。但到目前為止,加拿大是S-92的唯一一個軍方客戶,因此其需要承擔全部的系統集成和為海上使用而做的修改的費用。而在研發過程中,適配性和專案管理問題也逐漸浮現出來。
CH-148 MHP:系統及專案
加拿大的海軍直升機項目(MHP)原本選擇的方案是EH101,但由於了可靠性和成熟度的問題放棄了該方案。目前該方案命名為CH-149“鸕鷀”,用於搜救任務。
最終加拿大選擇了S-92。但到2000年為止,這個採購28架直升機的項目的費用已經增長到28億加拿大元,並於2003年增長到31億。到2010年為止,該項目費用增長到62億,且CH-124“海王”直升機仍需繼續使用以應付CH-148的延期。
S-92“超級鷹”是在H-60基礎上開發的一個重大改型。該機的複合材料使用比例比H-60有了顯著提高,並換裝了發動機,採用了後斜坡艙門構型以及其他一系列改動。該機與歐洲4國聯合研製的NFH90較為相似,巧合的是NFH90項目也一再超期。
CH-148原定於2008年11月交付,但隨後推遲到2009年1月,然後再次推遲到2010年12月。隨後,加拿大宣佈就該合同進行重新談判,將交付日期繼續推遲。目前的專案進度要求是2012年6月開始交付換裝新發動機、具備完全作戰能力的CH-148,全部28架交付完成的時間則不會早於2013年底。
過渡性的CH-148於2010年12月開始交付,但該機在4個方面存在缺陷:
●任務系統軟體
●資訊存儲轉發能力/戰術資料交換能力(其與其他友軍單位之間的自動資料鏈交換)
●任務飛行航時(比合同要求少21分鐘)
●高溫環境下的單發使用性能
其中前兩個問題可通過升級軟體及電子設備解決,後兩個問題有望在換裝了新的發動機後解決。而這些升級改進顯然還需要進行大量的試驗。(中國航空工業發展研究中心 李昊)
http://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/Canadas-CH-148-Cyclones-Better-Late-Than-Never-05223/
Canada’s CH-148 Cyclones: Better Late Than Never?
May 18, 2011 12:10 EDT
Canada’s Maritime Helicopter Replacement Program has been a textbook military procurement program over its long history. Unfortunately, it has been a textbook example of what not to do. While Canada’s Sea King helicopter fleet aged and deteriorated to potentially dangerous levels, political pettiness and lack of concern turned a straightforward off-the-shelf buy into a 25+ year long odyssey of cancellations, lawsuits, rebids, and more. Eventually, the Canadian military settled on Sikorsky’s H-92 Superhawk as the basis of its new CH-148 Cyclone Maritime Helicopter, which will serve from the decks of Canada’s naval ships and bases.
The civilian S-92 has gone on to some commercial success. To date, however, Canada has been the H-92’s only military customer – with all of the associated systems integration and naval conversion burdens. There are also deeper questions being raised concerning both the machines’ fitness, and DND’s conduct of the program as a whole. This article covers the rationale for, history of, and developments within Canada’s Maritime Helicopter Program…
The 5-bladed EH101 had been the Maritime Helicopter Program’s initial winner, and a civilian version currently serves in a search-and-rescue role as the CH-149 Cormorant. Canadian experiences with this type have been strained, however, due to reliability and readiness issues.
In the end, Canada chose a different platform, but the ride has been rough. In 2000, program costs for 28 maritime helicopters were estimated at C$ 2.8 billion. That escalated to C$ 3.1 billion in 2003, and by 2010, the cost of purchasing, providing 20 years of in-service support for, training personnel for, and extra spending to keep the CH-124 Sea King fleet operational during project delays, had hit C$ 6.2 billion. Many of those delays arose because a project touted as an off-the-shelf buy became nothing less than the development of a new helicopter platform for the global military market.
The H-92 Superhawk platform Canada chose for its “CH-148 Cyclone” maritime helicopters is a larger derivative of the ubiquitous H-60 family that comprise most of the US Navy’s current fleet. it makes heavier use of rust-proof composite materials, and also sports uprated engines, a rear ramp, and other features that place it in a similar class to Europe’s delayed NH90 NFH model, whose schedule has also slipped until it is also expected to become fully operational around 2012-2013.
Initial specifications called for GE’s 3,000 hp class CT7-8C, but weight growth will force another engine upgrade before the final design is ready. Standard self-sealing fuel tanks can carry up to 3,030 kg of fuel, and an in-flight refuelling probe allows in-air refueling.
Emergency flotation systems under the cockpit and in the tailboom are automatically deployed and are expected to work up to Sea State 5 conditions. If they fail, or aren’t practical, a 15-man life raft is installed in each sponson.
The 17 cubic meter cabin is fitted with a cargo handling system with a centerline 1,814 kg/ 4,000 pound capacity cargo winch, floor rollers, and cargo tie-down points. A 6 foot-wide aft ramp allows easy and fast loading and unloading of cargo and troops. A 272 kg/ 600 pound capacity hydraulic rescue hoist can reportedly be added to the helicopter if necessary.
Initial CH-148 delivery was originally scheduled for November 2008, but that was moved to January 2009, then pushed back again to December 2010. In the wake of a very vague announcement about contract renegotiation and further program delays, observers began questioning whether the program’s initial dates were ever realistic, and whether even the revised dates can be depended upon. Their suspicions were justified when it was revealed that fully operational CH-148s with upgraded engines wouldn’t begin delivery until June 2012, and the full fleet of 28 won’t be delivered until the end of 2013.
Overall, the CH-148 interim helicopters accepted beginning in December 2010 will be deficient in 4 areas:
Mission system software;
Messaging functionality/ tactical data exchange capability (automated data-link exchanges of tactical data between designated units, including the ships and aircraft);
Mission flight endurance (21 minute deficiency vs. contract);
Single engine operation at high temperature.
The first 2 issues will be solved with software and electronics upgrades. The latter 2 issues are expected to be solved by uprated turboshaft engines. All of these upgrades will, of course, require extensive testing.
The basic S-92 helicopter is assembled in Stratford, CT, but key parts are made elsewhere. Industrial partners for the S-92 include:
AIDC of Taiwan (Flight deck);
Embraer of Brazil (Front of the sponsons, Landing gear, Fuel tank integration);
Gamesa of Spain (Cabin interior, Aft fuselage, Tail boom, Upper fuselage Transmission housing);
Jingdezhen Helicopter Group / CATIC of China (Vertical tail, Horizontal stabilizer);
Mitsubishi of Japan (Main cabin)
CH-148 military systems partners include:
BAE Systems (Fly-by-wire and controls system, AN/ALQ-144Av5 countermeasures system);
FLIR systems (Star SAFIRE-III surveillance and targeting turrets);
GE Aero engines (CT7-8C turboshaft initially);
General Dynamics Canada (Integrated Mission System and Sonobuoy Acoustic Processing System);
L-3 (HELRAS sonar);
Lockheed Martin (RWR/ESM (Radar warning & location identifier) based on the MH-60R’s AN/ALQ-210);
Martin Baker (Crashworthy seats);
Rockwell Collins (avionics incl. integrated cockpit and EyeHUD helmet-mounted display, Link 11 tactical datalink);
Telephonics (AN/APS-143B maritime radar)