ARCHER (under pressure) May and I had a frank talk in Florida. Probably our first. She wants a long engagement to give me time...
ELLEN Time to give her up for another woman?
ARCHER If I want to.
ELLEN That's very noble.
ARCHER Yes. But it's ridiculous.
ELLEN Why? Because there is no other woman?
ARCHER No. Because I don't mean to marry anyone else.
ELLEN This other woman...does she love you, too?
ARCHER There is no other woman. I mean, the person May was thinking of...was neve.(slowly)...she guessed the truth. There is another woman. But not the one she thinks.
[He sits down beside her and takes her hands, unclasping them. She gets up and moves away from him]
ELLEN Don't make love to me. Too many people have done that.
ARCHER I've never made love to you. But you are the woman I would have married if it had been possible for either of us.
ELLEN Possible? You can say that when you're the one who's made it impossible.
ARCHER I've made it...
ELLEN Isn't it you who made me give up divorcing? Didn't you talk to me, here in this room, about sacrifice and sparing scandal because my family was going to be your family? And I did what you asked me. For May's sake. And for yours.
ARCHER But there were things in your husband's letter...
ELLEN I had nothing to fear from that letter. Absolutely nothing. You were just afraid of scandal for yourself, and for May.
[Ellen starts crying]
ARCHER Ellen. No. Nothing's done that can't be undone. I'm still free. You can be, too.
[He's holding her. He kisses her and she kisses him back passionately. She breaks away and they stare at each other. Then she shakes her head]
ARCHER No! Everything is different. Do you see me marrying May now?
ELLEN Would you ask her that question? Would you?
ARCHER I have to ask her. It's too late to do anything else.
ELLEN You say that because it's easy, not because it's true.
ARCHER This has changed everything
ELLEN No. The good things can't change. All that you've done for me, Newland, that I never knew. Going to the van der Luydens because people refused to meet me. Announcing you engagement at the ball so there would be two families standing behind me instead of one. I never understood how dreadful people thought I was.
(She sees him looking at her questioningly)
ELLEN Granny blurted it out one day. I was stupid, I never thought. New York seemed so kind and glad to see me. But there was no one as kind as you. They never knew what it meant to be tempted. But you did. You understood. You hated happiness brought by disloyalty and cruelty and indifference. I'd never known that before, and it's better than anything I've known.
[She speaks in a very low voice. Suddenly he kneels. The tip of her satin shoe shows under her dress. He kisses it. She bends over him]
ELLEN Newland. You couldn't be happy if it meant being cruel. If we act any other way I'll be making you act against what I love in you most. And I can't go back to that way of thinking. Don't you see? I can't love you unless I give you up.
[Archer springs to his feet]
ARCHER And Beaufort, with his orchids? Can you love him? (furious) May is ready to give me up!
ELLEN (quietly) Three days after you pleaded with her to advance your engagement she will give you up?
ARCHER She refused! That gives me the right...
ELLEN The right? The same kind of ugly right as my husband claims in his letters?
ARCHER No, of course not! But if we do this now...afterward, it will only be worse for everyone if we...
ELLEN (almost screaming) No, no, no! |